Civil Services Examination · प्रश्न 131
Examine the following statements: 1. All colours are pleasant. 2. Some colours are pleasant. 3. No colour is pleasant. 4. Some colours are not pleasant. Given that the statement 4 is true, what can be definitely concluded?
उत्तर देखें और व्याख्याव्याख्या देखें
उत्तर: (B) 1 is false
Given Premise: Statement 4 ('Some colours are not pleasant', an O-proposition in classical logic) is True. Identify Contradictory Statement: In the Square of Opposition, the Universal Affirmative ('All colours are pleasant', Statement 1) and the Particular Negative ('Some colours are not pleasant', Statement 4) are strict contradictories — they cannot both be true and cannot both be false. Check Statements 2 & 3: If some colours are not pleasant, it is possible that some other colours are pleasant (Statement 2 True, Statement 3 False) OR that no colour at all is pleasant (Statement 2 False, Statement 3 True) ⇒ neither 2 nor 3 can be definitely concluded. Result: Only '1 is false' can be definitely concluded. Shortcut: 'Some are not P' is the exact logical negation of 'All are P' ⇒ Statement 1 must be false! सही उत्तर: (b) 1 is false
