UPSC PYQPrelims 1997

Civil Services Examination · प्रश्न 143

Consider the following: I. Saxena, David, Jain and Kumar were District Collectors at places P, Q, R and S respectively in 1970. II. In 1972 they were transferred. Saxena and Jain interchanged places. Kumar and David also interchanged places. III. One year later in 1973 they were again transferred such that David and Jain interchanged places and Saxena and Kumar were also interchanged. What should be the next round of transfers so that all the four persons could have been posted at all the four places?

  1. Interchange Saxena and David as well as Jain and Kumar

  2. Interchange Saxena and Kumar as well as David and Jain

  3. Interchange David and Kumar as well as Saxena and Jain

  4. It is not possible for all the four persons to have been posted at all the four places

उत्तर देखें और व्याख्याव्याख्या देखें

उत्तर: (A) Interchange Saxena and David as well as Jain and Kumar

व्याख्या

Given: Track the postings of (Saxena, David, Jain, Kumar) across each transfer year: • 1970: Saxena = P, David = Q, Jain = R, Kumar = S. • 1972 (Saxena ↔ Jain; Kumar ↔ David): Saxena = R, David = S, Jain = P, Kumar = Q. • 1973 (David ↔ Jain; Saxena ↔ Kumar): Saxena = Q, David = P, Jain = S, Kumar = R. Finding the Unvisited Place for Each Officer: • Saxena has visited {P, R, Q} ⇒ needs S (currently held by Jain). • Jain has visited {R, P, S} ⇒ needs Q (currently held by Saxena) ⇒ Interchange Saxena and Jain. • David has visited {Q, S, P} ⇒ needs R (currently held by Kumar). • Kumar has visited {S, Q, R} ⇒ needs P (currently held by David) ⇒ Interchange David and Kumar. Result: Mathematically, option (c) 'Interchange David and Kumar as well as Saxena and Jain' is the exact solution; however, the provided PDF answer key marks (a). सही उत्तर: (a) Interchange Saxena and David as well as Jain and Kumar

उत्तर समझाने वाला चित्र