RRB NTPC · Question 12
In this question, a question is followed by two statements numbered (I) and (II). You have to decide whether the data provided in the statements are sufficient to answer the question. Read both the statements and decide the appropriate answer. Question: Among 5 trees, L, M, N, T and V each having a different height, which tree is the shortest? Statements: (I) V is shorter than N but taller than T. M is taller than T. (II) L is taller than only one tree.
Show answer & explanationShow explanation
Answer: (A) Both statements I and II together (and not statement 1 alone or statement II alone) are sufficient to answer the question
GIVEN / CONCEPT: Five trees L, M, N, T, and V have different heights. Statement (I): N > V > T and M > T. Statement (II): L is taller than only one tree. Step 1 (Relation / Equation): From Statement (I) alone ⇒ N, V, and M are all taller than T (at least 3 trees are taller than T), but L's height relative to T is unknown, so (I) alone is insufficient Step 2 (Simplification / Calculation): From Statement (II) alone ⇒ L is the second-shortest tree (taller than only 1 tree), which alone does not identify the shortest tree Step 3 (Verification / Deduction): Combining (I) and (II) ⇒ Since N, V, and M are all taller than T, T is either shortest or 2nd-shortest; since L occupies the 2nd-shortest position, T must be the shortest tree (N/M > V > L > T) RESULT / TAKEAWAY: Both statements I and II together are sufficient to answer the question. Correct Answer: (a) Both statements I and II together (and not statement 1 alone or statement II alone) are sufficient to answer the question
