SSC PYQTier 1 2024

SSC CGL – Combined Graduate Level Examination · Question 11

Three statements are given, followed by three conclusions numbered I, II and III. Assuming the statements to be true, even if they seem to be at variance with commonly known facts, decide which of the conclusions logically follow(s) from the statements. Statements: All pages are diaries. Some diaries are books. All books are notebooks. Conclusions: I. No page is a notebook. II. All pages are notebooks. III. All diaries being notebooks is a possibility.

  1. Both conclusion I and II follow

  2. Only conclusions I and III follow

  3. Only conclusion II follows

  4. Only conclusion III follows

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (D) Only conclusion III follows

Explanation

Analyze statements: • All pages are diaries (Pages ⊆ Diaries). • Some diaries are books (Diaries ∩ Books ≠ ∅). • All books are notebooks (Books ⊆ Notebooks). Evaluate conclusions: • Conclusion I ('No page is a notebook'): Pages and notebooks have no negative condition preventing overlap, so this definite negative does not follow. • Conclusion II ('All pages are notebooks'): No definite rule forces all pages inside notebooks, so this definite positive does not follow. • Conclusion III ('All diaries being notebooks is a possibility'): Since 'Some diaries are books' and 'All books are notebooks', all diaries can potentially be inside notebooks without violating any premise. Hence, this possibility is TRUE. Conclusion: Only conclusion III follows. Correct Answer: (d) Only conclusion III follows

Diagram explaining the answer