SSC PYQComputer Based Examination 2024

SSC MTS – Multi-Tasking (Non-Technical) Staff & Havaldar Examination · Question 30

Read the given statement(s) and conclusions carefully. Assuming that the information given in the statements is true, even if it appears to be at variance with commonly known facts, decide which of the given conclusions logically follow(s) from the statement(s). Statements: Some kites are rocks. All rocks are stones. Conclusions: (I) At least some kites are stones. (II) All stones are rocks.

  1. Only conclusion (II) follows.

  2. Neither conclusion (I) nor (II) follows.

  3. Only conclusion (I) follows.

  4. Both conclusions (I) and (II) follow.

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (A) Only conclusion (II) follows.

Explanation

Diagram: Rocks lie inside Stones, and Kites overlap Rocks. Conclusion I: The kites that are rocks are also stones, so at least some kites are stones → follows. Conclusion II: 'All rocks are stones' cannot be reversed; some stones may not be rocks → does not follow. Rule: 'Some A are B' + 'All B are C' → 'Some A are C'. Key note: Both the English and the Hindi papers mark option (a) 'Only conclusion (II) follows'. By the standard syllogism rules only conclusion (I) follows, which is option (c). The official key is kept here but should be treated as doubtful. Correct Answer: (a) Only conclusion (II) follows. (as per the official key; logically (c) Only conclusion (I) follows)

Diagram explaining the answer