UPSC PYQPrelims 1995

Civil Services Examination · Question 133

Examine the following statements: I watch TV only if I am bored. I am never bored when I have my brother’s company. Whenever I go to the theatre, I take my brother along. Which one of the following conclusions is valid in the context of the above statements?

  1. If I am bored, I watch TV

  2. If I am bored, I seek my brother’s company

  3. If I am not with my brother, then I watch TV

  4. If I am not bored, I do not watch TV

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (D) If I am not bored, I do not watch TV

Explanation

Translate Statements into Logic: Let W = 'I watch TV' and B = 'I am bored'. The statement 'I watch TV only if I am bored' means that being bored is a necessary condition for watching TV: ⇒ W → B (If I watch TV, then I am bored). Apply Contrapositive Rule: A conditional statement (W → B) is always logically equivalent to its contrapositive (¬B → ¬W): ⇒ ¬B → ¬W ('If I am not bored, I do not watch TV'). Why Other Options Fail: Option (a) 'B → W' commits the fallacy of affirming the consequent (you might be bored and still not watch TV); option (c) commits the fallacy of denying the antecedent. Result: Conclusion (d) 'If I am not bored, I do not watch TV' is logically valid. Shortcut: 'A only if B' ≡ 'If not B, then not A'. Correct Answer: (d) If I am not bored, I do not watch TV

Diagram explaining the answer