UPSC PYQPrelims 1995

Civil Services Examination · Question 146

The price fluctuations of 4 scrips in a stock market in the four quarters of a year are shown in the table below. Four different investors had the following portfolios of investment in the four companies throughout the year: Portfolios: Investor 1: 10 of A, 20 of B, 30 of C and 40 of D Investor 2: 40 of A, 10 of B, 20 of C and 30 of D Investor 3: 30 of A, 40 of B, 10 of C and 20 of D Investor 4: 20 of A, 30 of B, 40 of C and 10 of D

Figure given in the question

In the light of the above which one of the following statements is correct?

  1. Investor 2 has made the best investment

  2. Investor 1 has made the best investment

  3. Investor 2 suffered a net loss during the year

  4. Investor 3 suffered a net loss during the year

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (B) Investor 1 has made the best investment

Explanation

Evaluate Each Scrip's Annual Performance: ⇒ Scrip A: +10% − 15% + 10% − 10% = −5% simple (−7.44% compounded) → Worst performer. ⇒ Scrip B: +2% + 1% + 2% + 2% = +7% simple (+7.18% compounded) → Gain. ⇒ Scrip C: +1% + 1% − 5% − 1% = −4% simple (−4.06% compounded) → Loss. ⇒ Scrip D: +20% − 15% + 30% − 10% = +25% simple (+19.34% compounded) → Best performer by far. Compare Portfolios: Investor 1 holds the maximum units (40) of the best-performing Scrip D and the minimum units (10) of the worst-performing Scrip A, achieving the highest gain (+9.70 simple / +7.21 compound). Check Net Loss Claims: Both Investor 2 (+5.40 simple / +2.73 compound) and Investor 3 (+5.90 simple / +4.10 compound) earned positive net gains (so c and d are false). Result: Investor 1 has made the best investment. Shortcut: Scrip D is a huge winner (+25%) and Scrip A is the biggest loser (−5%); Investor 1 has the highest D (40) and lowest A (10). Correct Answer: (b) Investor 1 has made the best investment

Diagram explaining the answer