Civil Services Examination · Question 135
Two important characteristics of a hypothesis are that it should be testable and that it should be stated in a manner that it can be refuted. Which one of the following hypotheses, fulfils these characteristics?
Show answer & explanationShow explanation
Answer: (A) Intelligent persons have good memory
Concept: Apply the philosophy of science criteria (Karl Popper's testability and falsifiability/refutability) to each statement. Evaluate Option a: ⇒ 'Intelligent persons have good memory' asserts a general empirical relationship between two measurable variables (intelligence and memory); it can be tested using psychometric tests and readily refuted if intelligent individuals are found to have poor memory. Eliminate Options b, c & d: ⇒ (b) 'Some birds are animals' is a definitional tautology (true by definition, hence irrefutable); (c) 'Some businessmen are dishonest' is a particular existential statement ('some X are Y') which cannot be falsified by counter-examples; and (d) 'All men are mortal' cannot be refuted within any finite experimental observation period because proving a person immortal would require infinite time. Result: 'Intelligent persons have good memory' fulfils both characteristics of a scientific hypothesis. Correct Answer: (a) Intelligent persons have good memory
