UPSC PYQPrelims 1996

Civil Services Examination · Question 135

Two important characteristics of a hypothesis are that it should be testable and that it should be stated in a manner that it can be refuted. Which one of the following hypotheses, fulfils these characteristics?

  1. Intelligent persons have good memory

  2. Some birds are animals

  3. Some businessmen are dishonest

  4. All men are mortal

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (A) Intelligent persons have good memory

Explanation

Concept: Apply the philosophy of science criteria (Karl Popper's testability and falsifiability/refutability) to each statement. Evaluate Option a: ⇒ 'Intelligent persons have good memory' asserts a general empirical relationship between two measurable variables (intelligence and memory); it can be tested using psychometric tests and readily refuted if intelligent individuals are found to have poor memory. Eliminate Options b, c & d: ⇒ (b) 'Some birds are animals' is a definitional tautology (true by definition, hence irrefutable); (c) 'Some businessmen are dishonest' is a particular existential statement ('some X are Y') which cannot be falsified by counter-examples; and (d) 'All men are mortal' cannot be refuted within any finite experimental observation period because proving a person immortal would require infinite time. Result: 'Intelligent persons have good memory' fulfils both characteristics of a scientific hypothesis. Correct Answer: (a) Intelligent persons have good memory

Diagram explaining the answer