Civil Services Examination · Question 148
Examine the following statements: I. All members of Mohan's family are honest. II. Some members of Mohan's family are not employed. III. Some employed persons are not honest. IV. Some honest persons are not employed. Which of the following inferences can be drawn from the above statements?
Show answer & explanationShow explanation
Answer: (B) The employed members of Mohan's family are honest
Given / Concept: Let M = members of Mohan's family, H = honest persons, and E = employed persons. Apply Statement I: Statement I says 'All members of Mohan's family are honest' (M ⊂ H). Statement II says 'Some members of Mohan's family are not employed' (which Directly contradicts option a). Deduce for Employed Members of M: Since every member of Mohan's family belongs to H (M ⊂ H), the subset of Mohan's family who are employed (M ∩ E) is also a subset of M and therefore necessarily a subset of H ((M ∩ E) ⊂ M ⊂ H). Result: The employed members of Mohan's family are honest. Shortcut: If ALL of Mohan's family are honest, then ANY subset of Mohan's family (including the employed ones) must be honest ⇒ (b). Correct Answer: (b) The employed members of Mohan's family are honest
