UPSC PYQPrelims 2010

Civil Services Examination · Question 78

In a group of five persons A, B, C, D and E, there is a professor, a doctor and lawyer. A and D are unmarried ladies, and do not work. Of the married couple in the Group, E is the husband. B is the brother of A and is neither a doctor nor a lawyer. Who is the professor?

  1. B

  2. C

  3. A

  4. Cannot be determined with the available data

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (A) B

Explanation

Identify the Working Members: Out of the 5 persons (A, B, C, D, E), A and D are unmarried ladies who do not work ⇒ the 3 working professionals (Professor, Doctor, Lawyer) must be B, C, and E. Determine B's Profession: Since B is one of the three working professionals and is explicitly stated to be neither a doctor nor a lawyer ⇒ B must be the Professor. Result: B is the professor. Shortcut: Only 3 people work (B, C, E). B ≠ Doctor and B ≠ Lawyer ⇒ B = Professor! Correct Answer: (a) B

Diagram explaining the answer