UPSC PYQPrelims 2011

Civil Services Examination · Question 78

You are the officer-in-charge of a village administering distribution of vaccine in an isolated epidemic hit village, and you are left with only one vaccine. There is a requirement of that vaccine from the Gram Pradhan and also a poor villager. You are being pressurised by the Gram Pradhan to issue the vaccine to him. You would

  1. initiate the procedure to expedite the next supply without issuing the vaccine to either.

  2. arrange vaccine for the poor villager from the distributor of another area.

  3. ask both to approach a doctor and get an input about the urgency.

  4. arrange vaccine for the Gram Pradhan from the distributor of another area.

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (B) arrange vaccine for the poor villager from the distributor of another area.

Explanation

Given / Concept: In resource-scarce epidemic management, a proactive administrator solves the shortage so that both needy individuals receive the vaccine rather than withholding it or delaying. Evaluate Options: Withholding the available vaccine from both (a) is harmful; sending them to a doctor (c) only triages one and leaves the other unvaccinated. Resourceful Solution in Official Key: By issuing the available dose to one person and immediately arranging a second dose from the distributor of another area for the other person — options (b) and (d) — both the poor villager and the Gram Pradhan receive the vaccine. Result / Official Key Note: UPSC's official answer key for Q78 awarded full marks to (b) and (d) (even though many candidates consider (c) medically reasonable). Correct Answer: (b) arrange vaccine for the poor villager from the distributor of another area.

Diagram explaining the answer