UPSC PYQPrelims 2012

Civil Services Examination · Question 23

Consider the following statement: "Though quite expensive, television is not a luxury item, as one can learn many things through television." Which one of the following is a valid inference from the above statement?

  1. All expensive things are regarded as luxury.

  2. All essential things for learning are not luxury.

  3. Television is essential for learning.

  4. Television is not a luxury item.

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (D) Television is not a luxury item.

Explanation

Given: The statement says that although television is expensive, it is not a luxury item because one can learn many things through it. Eliminate a, b, c: Options (a) and (b) make universal claims ('All…') not supported by the sentence; option (c) claims television is 'essential' for learning, whereas the sentence only says one 'can learn' from it. Verify d: The core assertion concluded in the statement is that television is not a luxury item. Result: Option (d) is the valid inference. Correct Answer: (d) Television is not a luxury item.

Diagram explaining the answer