UPSC PYQPrelims 2014

Civil Services Examination · Question 51

“Liberty, therefore, is never real unless the Government can be called to account when it invades rights.” Which one of the following is the best justification of the above statement?

  1. In the realisation that the government can be brought to book in a court of law

  2. In identifying a man as a political unit in a way which distinguishes him from other citizens

  3. In a decentralized society wherein the basic needs of men can find satisfaction

  4. In the understanding that liberty and restraints are complementary

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (D) In the understanding that liberty and restraints are complementary

Explanation

Given / Concept: The quote (from Harold Laski) states that liberty is never real unless the government is held accountable when it invades rights. Analyze the underlying political philosophy: Liberty is not the absence of all restraint; rather, protecting individual liberty requires placing restraints/checks on the government's power so it cannot invade rights with impunity. Evaluate options: While (a) limits accountability only to courts, (d) captures the foundational principle that liberty and restraints are complementary. Result: The best philosophical justification of the statement is in the understanding that liberty and restraints are complementary. Correct Answer: (d) In the understanding that liberty and restraints are complementary

Diagram explaining the answer