UPSC PYQPrelims 2016

Civil Services Examination · Question 66

Read the following passage and answer the item that follows. Your answer to this item should be based on the passage only. Passage: "The conceptual difficulties in National Income comparisons between underdeveloped and industrialised countries are particularly serious because a part of the national output in various underdeveloped countries is produced without passing through the commercial channels." In the above statement, the author implies that:

  1. the entire national output produced and consumed in industrialized countries passes through commercial channels

  2. the existence of a non-commercialized sector in different underdeveloped countries renders the national income comparisons over countries difficult

  3. no part of national output should be produced and consumed without passing through commercial channels

  4. a part of the national output being produced and consumed without passing through commercial channels is a sign of underdevelopment

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (B) the existence of a non-commercialized sector in different underdeveloped countries renders the national income comparisons over countries difficult

Explanation

Concept: Restate the author's causal statement accurately without adding extreme or normative claims. Analyze text: Because part of the national output in underdeveloped countries does not pass through commercial channels (i.e. a non-commercialized sector exists), comparing national incomes across countries faces serious conceptual difficulties. Eliminate a, c, d: Option (a) uses the extreme word 'entire'; (c) adds a prescriptive 'should'; (d) turns an accounting difficulty into a definition of underdevelopment. Result: Option (b) accurately captures the author's implication. Correct Answer: (b) the existence of a non-commercialized sector in different underdeveloped countries renders the national income comparisons over countries difficult

Diagram explaining the answer