UPSC PYQPrelims 2017

Civil Services Examination · Question 30

P = (40% of A) + (65% of B) and Q = (50% of A) + (50% of B), where A is greater than B. In this context, which of the following statements is correct?

  1. P is greater than Q.

  2. Q is greater than P.

  3. P is equal to Q.

  4. None of the above can be concluded with certainty.

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (D) None of the above can be concluded with certainty.

Explanation

Given: P = 0.40A + 0.65B and Q = 0.50A + 0.50B, with A > B. Find P − Q: P − Q = (0.40A + 0.65B) − (0.50A + 0.50B) ⇒ P − Q = 0.15B − 0.10A = 0.05(3B − 2A). Test Cases with A > B: If B = 100 and A = 120, P = 113 > Q = 110; if B = 100 and A = 150, P = 125 = Q; if B = 100 and A = 200, P = 145 < Q = 150 (and if A, B are negative with A > B, e.g. A = 0, B = −100, Q > P). Result: None of the relations P > Q, Q > P, or P = Q can be concluded with certainty. Correct Answer: (d) None of the above can be concluded with certainty.

Diagram explaining the answer