Civil Services Examination · Question 40
Eight students A, B, C, D, E, F, G and H sit around a circular table, equidistant from each other, facing the centre of the table, not necessarily in the same order. B and D sit neither adjacent to C nor opposite to C. A sits in between E and D, and F sits in between B and H. Which one of the following is definitely correct?
Show answer & explanationShow explanation
Answer: (D) None of the above
Given: 8 seats (0 to 7) around a circle. Fix C at seat 0. Then seats 1, 7 are adjacent to C, and seat 4 is opposite to C. Thus B and D must occupy two seats from {2, 3, 5, 6}. Block Constraints: A sits between E and D (block E-A-D or D-A-E of length 3), and F sits between B and H (block B-F-H or H-F-B of length 3). Construct Valid Counterexamples: ⇒ Arrangement 1: (0:C, 1:G, 2:D, 3:A, 4:E, 5:B, 6:F, 7:H). Here D=2, B=5 (neither in {1,4,7}), D-A-E is at 2-3-4, B-F-H is at 5-6-7. In this valid arrangement: B is between E and F (not A and G), C is opposite E (not G), and E(4) is opposite C(0) (not F(6)). ⇒ Arrangement 2: (0:C, 1:E, 2:A, 3:D, 4:G, 5:B, 6:F, 7:H) is also valid. Result: None of (a), (b), or (c) is definitely true in all valid arrangements. Correct Answer: (d) None of the above
