UPSC PYQPrelims 2023

Civil Services Examination · Question 38

Consider the following statements: 1. A is older than B. 2. C and D are of the same age. 3. E is the youngest. 4. F is younger than D. 5. F is older than A. How many statements given above are required to determine the oldest person/persons?

  1. Only two

  2. Only three

  3. Only four

  4. All five

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (D) All five

Explanation

Combine Statements 1, 2, 4, 5: From (2) C = D, (4) D > F, (5) F > A, and (1) A > B, we get the chain C = D > F > A > B. Role of Statement 3: Without Statement 3 ('E is the youngest'), we have no information about E, so E could be older than C and D. Check Necessity of Every Statement: Dropping (1) leaves B unbounded; dropping (2) leaves C unbounded; dropping (4) or (5) breaks the chain between {C, D} and {F, A, B}. Result: All five statements are required to determine that C and D are the oldest. Correct Answer: (d) All five

Diagram explaining the answer