Other Exams PYQWritten Exam 2021ScienceChemistry: Matter & Atomic Structure

UP Super TET · Question 103

Which of the following compound gives the most stable carbonium ion during dehydration reaction?

  1. CH₃–CH(CH₃)–CH₂OH (Isobutyl alcohol)

  2. CH₃–CH(OH)–CH₂–CH₃ (sec-Butyl alcohol)

  3. (CH₃)₃C–OH (tert-Butyl alcohol)

  4. CH₃–CH₂–CH₂–CH₂–OH (n-Butyl alcohol)

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (C) (CH₃)₃C–OH (tert-Butyl alcohol)

Explanation

Among the given compounds, tert-butyl alcohol [(CH₃)₃C–OH, 2-methylpropan-2-ol] directly gives the most stable carbonium ion (carbocation) during acid-catalyzed dehydration. Upon protonation and loss of a water molecule (–H₂O), (CH₃)₃C–OH forms the tertiary (3°) tert-butyl carbocation [(CH₃)₃C⁺], which is exceptionally stable due to the electron-releasing inductive effect (+I) of three methyl groups and hyperconjugation involving 9 alpha-hydrogens (9 α-H). Why other options are wrong: • (a) CH₃–CH(CH₃)–CH₂OH: A primary (1°) alcohol; direct C–O cleavage gives an unstable 1° isobutyl carbocation (only 1 α-H). • (b) CH₃–CH(OH)–CH₂–CH₃: A secondary (2°) alcohol; gives a 2° sec-butyl carbocation (5 α-H), which is less stable than 3°. • (d) CH₃–CH₂–CH₂–CH₂–OH: A primary (1°) alcohol; gives an unstable 1° n-butyl carbocation (2 α-H). Related Facts: • Stability order of carbocations: Tertiary (3°) > Secondary (2°) > Primary (1°) > Methyl (CH₃⁺). • Therefore, the ease of acid-catalyzed dehydration of alcohols also follows the order: 3° alcohol > 2° alcohol > 1° alcohol. Correct Answer: (c) (CH₃)₃C–OH (tert-Butyl alcohol)

Diagram explaining the answer