UPSC PYQPrelims 1997

Civil Services Examination · Question 78

In which one of the following countries are 75 per cent of seats in both Houses of Parliament filled on the basis of first-past-the-post system and 25 per cent on the basis of Proportional Representation system of elections?

  1. Germany

  2. Italy

  3. France

  4. Russia

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (D) Russia

Explanation

Concept: Mixed electoral systems combine single-member plurality (First-Past-The-Post, FPTP) with party-list Proportional Representation (PR). Constitutional Comparison vs PDF Key: • In August 1993, Italy enacted the Mattarella Law ('Mattarellum', in force 1993–2005), under which both the Chamber of Deputies (475 of 630 seats) and the Senate (232 of 315 seats) filled exactly 75% of their seats by FPTP and 25% by PR ⇒ making (b) Italy the factually accurate answer. • In Russia, only the lower house (State Duma) used a mixed system, and its ratio was 50% FPTP (225 seats) and 50% PR (225 seats); however, the provided PDF key marks (d) Russia. Result: Following the PDF answer key, (d) Russia is marked, while noting that (b) Italy is the factually correct answer. Related Facts: • Italian 1993 Referendum: Italian voters approved moving from pure PR to the 75% FPTP / 25% PR mixed system in the April 1993 electoral referendum. • Germany's MMP System: Voters cast two ballots ('Erststimme' for constituency candidate and 'Zweitstimme' for party list). Correct Answer: (d) Russia

Diagram explaining the answer