UPSC PYQPrelims 2011

Civil Services Examination · Question 14

Directions for the following item: The following pie charts show the break up of disease categories recorded in the patients from two towns, Town A and Town B. Pie charts plot the disease categories as percentage of the total number of patients. Based on these, answer the item that follows the charts.

Figure given in the question

Town A: Diabetes 18%, High BP 13%, Heart Disease 22%, Obesity 34%, Others 13% Town B: Diabetes 24%, High BP 19%, Heart Disease 30%, Obesity 28%, Others 20% Which of the two towns has a higher number of persons with Diabetes?

  1. Town A

  2. Town B

  3. Same in Town A and Town B

  4. No inference can be drawn

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (D) No inference can be drawn

Explanation

Given / Concept: Absolute number of patients in a category = (Percentage ÷ 100) × Total number of patients in that town. Identify Missing Data: The pie charts give the percentage of Diabetes in Town A (18%) and Town B (24%), but the total number of patients in Town A and Town B is not given. Test Cases: If Town A has 1,000 patients and Town B has 500, Town A has more (180 > 120) ⇒ If both have 1,000 patients, Town B has more (240 > 180). Result: Without the base totals, no inference can be drawn about the actual number of persons. Correct Answer: (d) No inference can be drawn

Diagram explaining the answer