Civil Services Examination · Question 14
Directions for the following item: The following pie charts show the break up of disease categories recorded in the patients from two towns, Town A and Town B. Pie charts plot the disease categories as percentage of the total number of patients. Based on these, answer the item that follows the charts.

Town A: Diabetes 18%, High BP 13%, Heart Disease 22%, Obesity 34%, Others 13% Town B: Diabetes 24%, High BP 19%, Heart Disease 30%, Obesity 28%, Others 20% Which of the two towns has a higher number of persons with Diabetes?
Show answer & explanationShow explanation
Answer: (D) No inference can be drawn
Given / Concept: Absolute number of patients in a category = (Percentage ÷ 100) × Total number of patients in that town. Identify Missing Data: The pie charts give the percentage of Diabetes in Town A (18%) and Town B (24%), but the total number of patients in Town A and Town B is not given. Test Cases: If Town A has 1,000 patients and Town B has 500, Town A has more (180 > 120) ⇒ If both have 1,000 patients, Town B has more (240 > 180). Result: Without the base totals, no inference can be drawn about the actual number of persons. Correct Answer: (d) No inference can be drawn
