UPSC PYQPrelims 2011

Civil Services Examination · Question 15

Directions for the following item: The following pie charts show the break up of disease categories recorded in the patients from two towns, Town A and Town B. Pie charts plot the disease categories as percentage of the total number of patients. Based on these, answer the item that follows the charts.

Figure given in the question

Town A: Diabetes 18%, High BP 13%, Heart Disease 22%, Obesity 34%, Others 13% Town B: Diabetes 24%, High BP 19%, Heart Disease 30%, Obesity 28%, Others 20% What can we say about persons with more than one disease from these graphs?

  1. There are likely to be persons with more than one disease in Town A.

  2. There are likely to be persons with more than one disease in Town B.

  3. There are likely to be persons with more than one disease in both Towns A and B.

  4. No inference can be drawn.

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (B) There are likely to be persons with more than one disease in Town B.

Explanation

Given / Concept: If disease categories are mutually exclusive, their percentages of total patients must sum to 100%; a sum above 100% indicates overlapping categories (patients having multiple diseases). Sum for Town A: 18% + 13% + 22% + 34% + 13% = 100%. Sum for Town B: 24% + 19% + 30% + 28% + 20% = 121% > 100% ⇒ at least 21% of patients are counted in more than one disease category. Result: There are likely to be persons with more than one disease in Town B. Correct Answer: (b) There are likely to be persons with more than one disease in Town B.

Diagram explaining the answer