UPSC PYQPrelims 2011

Civil Services Examination · Question 48

Consider the following argument: "In order to be a teacher one must graduate from college. All poets are poor. Some Mathematicians are poets. No college graduate is poor." Which one of the following is not a valid conclusion regarding the above argument?

  1. Some Mathematicians are not teachers.

  2. Some teachers are not Mathematicians.

  3. Teachers are not poor.

  4. Poets are not teachers.

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (B) Some teachers are not Mathematicians.

Explanation

Given / Concept: Translate premises into set relations: Teachers ⊆ Graduates; Poets ⊆ Poor; Graduates ∩ Poor = ∅; Mathematicians ∩ Poets ≠ ∅. Deduce Valid Conclusions: Since Teachers ⊆ Graduates and Graduates ∩ Poor = ∅, no Teacher is Poor ((c) is valid) ⇒ Since Poets ⊆ Poor, no Poet is a Teacher ((d) is valid) ⇒ Since some Mathematicians are Poets, those Mathematicians are not Teachers ((a) is valid). Identify Invalid Conclusion: Even though some Mathematicians are not Teachers, the entire set of Teachers can still be a subset of the non-poet Mathematicians ⇒ 'Some teachers are not Mathematicians' does not logically follow. Result: Option (b) is not a valid conclusion. Correct Answer: (b) Some teachers are not Mathematicians.

Diagram explaining the answer