UPSC PYQPrelims 2012

Civil Services Examination · Question 16

Consider the following statements: 1. All artists are whimsical. 2. Some artists are drug addicts. 3. Frustrated people are prone to become drug addicts. From the above three statements it may be concluded that

  1. Artists are frustrated.

  2. Some drug addicts are whimsical.

  3. All frustrated people are drug addicts.

  4. Whimsical people are generally frustrated.

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (B) Some drug addicts are whimsical.

Explanation

Given: Statement 1 says all artists are whimsical (Artists ⊂ Whimsical); Statement 2 says some artists are drug addicts. Combine 1 & 2: Some artists are drug addicts + All artists are whimsical ⇒ Those drug addicts who are artists must also be whimsical. Eliminate Options: Statement 3 only says frustrated people are 'prone' to become drug addicts, so no definite link between frustrated people and artists/whimsical people holds. Result: Some drug addicts are whimsical. Correct Answer: (b) Some drug addicts are whimsical.

Diagram explaining the answer