UPSC PYQPrelims 2012

Civil Services Examination · Question 18

Examine the following statements: 1. Only those who have a pair of binoculars can become the members of the birdwatcher's club. 2. Some members of the birdwatcher's club have cameras. 3. Those members who have cameras can take part in photo-contests. Which of the following conclusions can be drawn from the above statements?

  1. All those who have a pair of binoculars are members of the birdwatcher's club.

  2. All members of the birdwatcher's club have a pair of binoculars.

  3. All those who take part in photo-contests are members of the birdwatcher's club.

  4. No conclusion can be drawn.

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (B) All members of the birdwatcher's club have a pair of binoculars.

Explanation

Concept: In logic, 'Only P can become Q' means P is a necessary condition for Q (i.e. All Q are P). Apply to Statement 1: Since only those with a pair of binoculars can become members of the birdwatcher's club ⇒ every member of the club must have a pair of binoculars. Eliminate Options: Option (a) reverses the implication, and option (c) assumes only club members can enter photo-contests. Result: All members of the birdwatcher's club have a pair of binoculars. Correct Answer: (b) All members of the birdwatcher's club have a pair of binoculars.

Diagram explaining the answer