UPSC PYQPrelims 2012

Civil Services Examination · Question 63

Consider the following statements: 1. All machines consume energy. 2. Electricity provides energy. 3. Electrically operated machines are cheap to maintain. 4. Electrically operated machines do not cause pollution. Which one of the following inferences can be drawn from the above statements?

  1. All machines are run by electric energy.

  2. There is no form of energy other than electricity.

  3. Most machines are operated on electric energy.

  4. Electrically operated machines are preferable to use.

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (D) Electrically operated machines are preferable to use.

Explanation

Given: All machines consume energy; electricity provides energy; electrically operated machines are cheap to maintain and do not cause pollution. Eliminate a, b, c: Knowing that machines consume energy and electricity provides energy does not imply that all (a) or most (c) machines use electricity, nor that no other energy form exists (b). Deduce d: Because electrically operated machines are both cheap to maintain (Statement 3) and pollution-free (Statement 4) ⇒ they are preferable to use. Result: Option (d) is the valid inference. Correct Answer: (d) Electrically operated machines are preferable to use.

Diagram explaining the answer