UPSC PYQPrelims 2012

Civil Services Examination · Question 64

Examine the following statements: 1. None but the rich can afford air-travel. 2. Some of those who travel by air become sick. 3. Some of those who become sick require treatment. Which one of the following conclusions can be drawn from the above statements?

  1. All the rich persons travel by air.

  2. Those who travel by air become sick.

  3. All the rich persons become sick.

  4. All those who travel by air are rich.

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (D) All those who travel by air are rich.

Explanation

Given: Statement 1 says 'None but the rich can afford air-travel' (i.e. Only the rich can travel by air). Translate 'None but': In logic, 'None but P are Q' (Only P are Q) is equivalent to 'All Q are P' ⇒ All those who travel by air are rich. Eliminate a, b, c: Option (a) reverses the subset relation; options (b) and (c) turn 'some' into 'all'. Result: All those who travel by air are rich. Correct Answer: (d) All those who travel by air are rich.

Diagram explaining the answer