UPSC PYQPrelims 2013

Civil Services Examination · Question 29

A, B, C, D and E belong to five different cities P, Q, R, S and T (not necessarily in that order). Each one of them comes from a different city. Further it is given that : 1. B and C do not belong to Q. 2. B and E do not belong to P and R. 3. A and C do not belong to R, S and T. 4. D and E do not belong to Q and T. Which one of the following statements is not correct ?

  1. C belongs to P

  2. D belongs to R

  3. A belongs to Q

  4. B belongs to S

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (D) B belongs to S

Explanation

Given: 5 persons {A, B, C, D, E} map one-to-one to 5 cities {P, Q, R, S, T}. Find C and A: Statement 3 says A and C do not belong to R, S, T ⇒ A, C ∈ {P, Q}. By Statement 1 (C ≠ Q), we get C = P and A = Q. Find E: Statements 2 and 4 state E does not belong to P, R, Q, T ⇒ E = S. Find B and D: Remaining cities for {B, D} are {R, T}. Since B ≠ R (Statement 2), we get B = T and D = R. Result: B belongs to T (not S), so '(d) B belongs to S' is not correct. Correct Answer: (d) B belongs to S

Diagram explaining the answer