UPSC PYQPrelims 2013

Civil Services Examination · Question 81

The Ilbert Bill controversy was related to the

  1. imposition of certain restrictions to carry arms by the Indians

  2. imposition of restrictions on newspapers and magazines published in Indian languages

  3. removal of disqualifications imposed on the Indian magistrates with regard to the trial of the Europeans

  4. removal of a duty on imported cotton cloth

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (C) removal of disqualifications imposed on the Indian magistrates with regard to the trial of the Europeans

Explanation

Concept: In 1883, during the viceroyalty of Lord Ripon, Sir Courtenay Peregrine Ilbert (Law Member of the Viceroy's Executive Council) introduced the Ilbert Bill to amend the Code of Criminal Procedure. Purpose of the Bill: Prior to 1883, Indian sessions judges and magistrates in the mofussil (country districts outside Presidency towns) were legally disqualified from trying European British subjects in criminal cases. The Ilbert Bill sought to remove this racial disqualification and place Indian and European judges on an equal footing. European Backlash: British planters, merchants and officials launched a fierce racial agitation ('White Mutiny'), forcing Ripon in January 1884 to amend the Bill so that Europeans tried by an Indian judge could claim a jury of which at least half the members were European. Result: The Ilbert Bill controversy was related to the removal of disqualifications imposed on Indian magistrates with regard to the trial of Europeans. Related Facts: • Match Other Options to Lord Lytton (1876–80): Option (a) refers to the Arms Act, 1878; Option (b) refers to the Vernacular Press Act, 1878; Option (d) refers to the abolition of import duties on British cotton goods in 1879. • Impact on Nationalism: The success of the organized European protest taught Indian nationalists the value of an all-India political organization, leading to the Indian National Conference (1883) and INC (1885). Correct Answer: (c) removal of disqualifications imposed on the Indian magistrates with regard to the trial of the Europeans

Diagram explaining the answer