UPSC PYQPrelims 2014

Civil Services Examination · Question 62

The number of deaths among the army personnel is 8 in 1000, but among the civilian population it is 20 per 1000. Which one of the following inferences can be drawn from this statement?

  1. It is better to join the army.

  2. The relationship is fortuitous.

  3. Quality of Life Index is very high within the armed forces.

  4. The groups cannot be compared due to their heterogeneity.

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (D) The groups cannot be compared due to their heterogeneity.

Explanation

Given / Concept: In vital statistics, crude mortality rates of two populations cannot be directly compared if their age and health compositions are fundamentally different (heterogeneous). Analyze the two groups: Army personnel consist of medically screened, physically fit adults of a specific age group, whereas the civilian population includes infants, very old people, and chronically ill patients. Result: The valid inference is that the groups cannot be compared due to their heterogeneity. Correct Answer: (d) The groups cannot be compared due to their heterogeneity.

Diagram explaining the answer