UPSC PYQPrelims 2015

Civil Services Examination · Question 17

Four persons A, B, C and D consisting of two married couples are in a group. Both the women are shorter than their respective husbands. A is the tallest among the four. C is taller than B. D is B's brother. In this context, which one of the following statements is not correct?

  1. All four have family ties.

  2. B is the shortest among the four.

  3. C is taller than D.

  4. A is B's husband.

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (C) C is taller than D.

Explanation

Given / Concept: Both women are shorter than their husbands. Since A is the tallest of all four, A must be a man (husband). Since D is B's brother, D is also a man (husband). Identify couples: Men = A, D; Women = B, C. Since D is B's brother, D cannot be married to B ⇒ D is C's husband and A is B's husband. Height order: Each wife is shorter than her husband (C < D and B < A), and we are given B < C. Since A is tallest: B < C < D < A. Result: C is shorter than D (her husband), so statement (c) 'C is taller than D' is not correct. Correct Answer: (c) C is taller than D.

Diagram explaining the answer