UPSC PYQPrelims 2015

Civil Services Examination · Question 20

All good athletes want to win and all athletes who want to win eat a well-balanced diet; therefore all athletes who do not eat a well-balanced diet are bad athletes. The best conclusion from this statement is that

  1. no bad athlete wants to win.

  2. no athlete who does not eat a well-balanced diet is a good athlete.

  3. every athlete who eats a well-balanced diet is a good athlete.

  4. all athletes who want to win are good athletes.

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (B) no athlete who does not eat a well-balanced diet is a good athlete.

Explanation

Given / Concept: Good Athletes ⊂ Athletes who want to win ⊂ Athletes who eat a well-balanced diet. Apply Contrapositive: Since every good athlete eats a well-balanced diet, anyone who does NOT eat a well-balanced diet cannot be a good athlete. Step 3 (Check options (a), (c), (d)): Converse statements like 'eat balanced diet ⇒ good athlete' (c) or 'want to win ⇒ good athlete' (d) are invalid; some bad athletes may also want to win (so (a) fails). Result: No athlete who does not eat a well-balanced diet is a good athlete. Correct Answer: (b) no athlete who does not eat a well-balanced diet is a good athlete.

Diagram explaining the answer