UPSC PYQPrelims 2015

Civil Services Examination · Question 21

Passage – 1: The richer States have a responsibility to cut down carbon emissions and promote clean energy investments. These are the States that got electricity, grew faster and now have high per capita income, making them capable of sharing India's burden of becoming eco-friendly. Delhi, for example, can help by generating its own clean electricity using solar rooftop panels or even help poor States finance their clean energy projects. It is no secret that State Electricity Boards, which control 95% of the distribution network, are neck-deep in losses. These losses further discourage State utilities from adopting renewable energy as it is more expensive than fossil fuels. Which among the following is the most logical and rational assumption that can be made from the above passage?

  1. The richer States must lead in the production and adoption of renewable energy.

  2. The poor States always have to depend on rich States for electricity.

  3. The State Electricity Boards can improve their finances by undertaking clean energy projects.

  4. The high economic disparity between the rich and poor States is the major cause of high carbon emissions in India.

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (A) The richer States must lead in the production and adoption of renewable energy.

Explanation

Given / Concept: The passage states that richer States grew faster, have high per capita income, and can bear the higher cost of clean energy. Identify the assumption: Arguing that richer States have a responsibility to promote clean energy investments assumes they must lead in producing and adopting renewable energy. Eliminate other options: (b) uses 'always depend' which is extreme; (c) contradicts the text that renewable energy is more expensive; (d) is not mentioned. Result: Option (a) is the most logical assumption. Correct Answer: (a) The richer States must lead in the production and adoption of renewable energy.

Diagram explaining the answer