UPSC PYQPrelims 2016

Civil Services Examination · Question 10

Consider the following statement: "We shall go either for a picnic or for trekking". Which of the following, if true, would falsify this claim?

  1. We go for a picnic but not for trekking

  2. Activities such as picnic and trekking are encouraged by the health authorities

  3. We go for trekking and not for picnic

  4. We do not go either for picnic or for trekking

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (D) We do not go either for picnic or for trekking

Explanation

Concept: A disjunctive claim 'Either P or Q' requires at least one of the two alternatives (P or Q) to occur. Evaluate a and c: In both (a) and (c), one of the two activities takes place, which satisfies the claim rather than falsifying it. Evaluate d: Negating 'Either P or Q' by De Morgan's Law gives 'Neither P nor Q' (¬P ∧ ¬Q). Result: Not going for either picnic or trekking directly falsifies the claim. Correct Answer: (d) We do not go either for picnic or for trekking

Diagram explaining the answer