UPSC PYQPrelims 2016

Civil Services Examination · Question 5

Read the following passage and answer the item that follows. Your answer to this item should be based on the passage only. Passage: In general, religious traditions stress our duty to god, or to some universal ethical principle. Our duties to one another derive from these. The religious concept of rights is primarily derived from our relationship to this divinity or principle and the implication it has on our other relationships. This correspondence between rights and duties is critical to any further understanding of justice. But, for justice to be practiced; virtue, rights and duties cannot remain formal abstractions. They must be grounded in a community (common unity) bound together by a sense of common union (communion). Even as a personal virtue, this solidarity is essential to the practice and understanding of justice. With reference to the passage, the following assumptions have been made: 1. Human relationships are derived from their religious traditions 2. Human beings can be duty bound only if they believe in god 3. Religious traditions are essential to practice and understand justice Which of these assumption(s) is/are valid?

  1. 1 only

  2. 2 and 3 only

  3. 1 and 3 only

  4. 1, 2 and 3

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (A) 1 only

Explanation

Concept: Check each assumption against the exact claims in Passage-2. Check Assumption 1: The passage states that our duties to one another and the implications on our relationships derive from religious traditions ⇒ Assumption 1 is valid. Check Assumption 2: The first sentence states 'duty to god, or to some universal ethical principle', refuting the 'only if they believe in god' condition ⇒ Assumption 2 is invalid. Check Assumption 3: The passage states that community solidarity (communion), not religious tradition itself, is essential to practice and understand justice ⇒ Assumption 3 is invalid. Result: Only assumption 1 is valid. Correct Answer: (a) 1 only

Diagram explaining the answer