UPSC PYQPrelims 2017

Civil Services Examination · Question 9

Directions for the following 2 (two) items : Consider the given information and answer the two items that follow. No supporters of 'party X', who knew Z and supported his campaign strategy, agreed for the alliance with 'party Y'; but some of them had friends in 'party Y'. With reference to the above information, which one among the following statements must be true?

  1. Some supporters of 'party Y' did not agree for the alliance with the 'party X'.

  2. There is at least one supporter of 'party Y' who knew some supporters of 'party X' as a friend.

  3. No supporters of 'party X' supported Z's campaign strategy.

  4. No supporters of 'party X' knew Z.

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (B) There is at least one supporter of 'party Y' who knew some supporters of 'party X' as a friend.

Explanation

Given: A subset of supporters of 'party X' (who knew Z and supported his strategy) did not agree to an alliance with 'party Y', but some of them had friends in 'party Y'. Deduction: Since 'some of them had friends in party Y', that subset is non-empty and has at least one friend in 'party Y'. Symmetry of Friendship: Therefore, there is at least one supporter of 'party Y' who knew some supporters of 'party X' as a friend. Result: Statement (b) must be true, while (c) and (d) are contradicted by 'some of them' and (a) is not stated. Correct Answer: (b) There is at least one supporter of 'party Y' who knew some supporters of 'party X' as a friend.

Diagram explaining the answer