UPSC PYQPrelims 2018

Civil Services Examination · Question 40

Which one of the following reflects the most appropriate relationship between law and liberty ?

  1. If there are more laws, there is less liberty.

  2. If there are no laws, there is no liberty.

  3. If there is liberty, laws have to be made by the people.

  4. If laws are changed too often, liberty is in danger.

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (B) If there are no laws, there is no liberty.

Explanation

Concept: Constitutional and philosophical relationship between Law and Liberty (John Locke's classical liberal principle). Philosophical Rule: In his 'Second Treatise of Civil Government' (1689), John Locke stated: 'The end of law is not to abolish or restrain, but to preserve and enlarge freedom... where there is no law, there is no freedom.' Application: In the absence of law, society reverts to a state of anarchy ('might is right') where no individual's life, rights, or liberty is secure from infringement by others ⇒ Law is the necessary condition that creates and protects liberty. Result: 'If there are no laws, there is no liberty' reflects the most appropriate relationship between law and liberty, making option (b) correct. Related Facts: • NCERT Class 11 (Political Theory — Freedom): Highlights that reasonable legal constraints are essential to prevent harm to others (J.S. Mill's 'Harm Principle') and enable everyone to enjoy liberty equally. • Indian Constitution (Articles 19 & 21): Fundamental freedoms under Article 19 are protected by law subject to 'reasonable restrictions', and Article 21 protects life and personal liberty 'according to procedure established by law'. • Ernest Barker & Laski: Both political thinkers emphasized that liberty is regulated freedom under the shelter of law. Correct Answer: (b) If there are no laws, there is no liberty.

Diagram explaining the answer