UPSC PYQPrelims 2019

Civil Services Examination · Question 13

Consider the following Statements and Conclusions : Statements : 1. Some rats are cats. 2. Some cats are dogs. 3. No dog is a cow. Conclusions : I. No cow is a cat. II. No dog is a rat. III. Some cats are rats. Which of the above conclusions is/are drawn from the statements?

  1. I, II and III

  2. Only I and II

  3. Only III

  4. Only II and III

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (C) Only III

Explanation

Concept: Represent the statements using Venn diagrams and check which conclusion holds in every possible diagram. Check Conclusions: ⇒ Conclusion I ('No cow is a cat'): Since only some cats are dogs and no dog is a cow, the remaining cats can still be cows. Hence I does not necessarily follow. ⇒ Conclusion II ('No dog is a rat'): Some rats are cats and some cats are dogs; the sets of rats and dogs may or may not intersect. Hence II does not follow. ⇒ Conclusion III ('Some cats are rats'): This is the direct converse of Statement 1 ('Some rats are cats'), which is always true. Result: Only Conclusion III follows. Correct Answer: (c) Only III

Diagram explaining the answer