Civil Services Examination · Question 80
Directions for the following 2 (two) items : Read the following statements S1 and S2 and answer the two items that follow : S1 : Twice the weight of Sohan is less than the weight of Mohan or that of Rohan. S2 : Twice the weight of Rohan is greater than the weight of Mohan or that of Sohan. Which one of the following statements is correct?
Show answer & explanationShow explanation
Answer: (B) Weight of Sohan is least
Analyze Statement S1: S1 states that 'Twice the weight of Sohan is less than the weight of Mohan or that of Rohan'. Official Key Interpretation: ⇒ Treating 'less than M or R' as meaning 2S is less than either one you compare it with (i.e., 2S < M and 2S < R): ⇒ Since weights are positive (S > 0), we have S < 2S < M and S < 2S < R. ⇒ Thus S < M and S < R, which means Sohan's weight is the least. Result: Weight of Sohan is least. (Note on Ambiguity: In strict mathematical logic, '2S < M or 2S < R' is satisfied even if only one inequality holds, e.g., M = 5, S = 10, R = 25 where 2S = 20 < R = 25 and 2R = 50 > M, S, which would make Mohan the least and favour (d); however, the official UPSC answer key is (b).) Correct Answer: (b) Weight of Sohan is least
