UPSC PYQPrelims 2019

Civil Services Examination · Question 80

Directions for the following 2 (two) items : Read the following statements S1 and S2 and answer the two items that follow : S1 : Twice the weight of Sohan is less than the weight of Mohan or that of Rohan. S2 : Twice the weight of Rohan is greater than the weight of Mohan or that of Sohan. Which one of the following statements is correct?

  1. Weight of Mohan is least

  2. Weight of Sohan is least

  3. Weight of Rohan is least

  4. 'Whose weight is least' cannot be determined

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (B) Weight of Sohan is least

Explanation

Analyze Statement S1: S1 states that 'Twice the weight of Sohan is less than the weight of Mohan or that of Rohan'. Official Key Interpretation: ⇒ Treating 'less than M or R' as meaning 2S is less than either one you compare it with (i.e., 2S < M and 2S < R): ⇒ Since weights are positive (S > 0), we have S < 2S < M and S < 2S < R. ⇒ Thus S < M and S < R, which means Sohan's weight is the least. Result: Weight of Sohan is least. (Note on Ambiguity: In strict mathematical logic, '2S < M or 2S < R' is satisfied even if only one inequality holds, e.g., M = 5, S = 10, R = 25 where 2S = 20 < R = 25 and 2R = 50 > M, S, which would make Mohan the least and favour (d); however, the official UPSC answer key is (b).) Correct Answer: (b) Weight of Sohan is least

Diagram explaining the answer