Civil Services Examination · Question 39
Consider two Statements and a Question : Statement-1 : Each of A and D is heavier than each of B, E and F, but none of them is the heaviest. Statement-2 : A is heavier than D, but is lighter than C. Question : Who is the heaviest among A, B, C, D and E? Which one of the following is correct in respect of the Statements and the Question?
Show answer & explanationShow explanation
Answer: (C) Both Statement-1 and Statement-2 are required to answer the Question
Check Statement-1 Alone: A, D > {B, E, F} and none of {A, D, B, E, F} is the heaviest. Since C is not mentioned in Statement-1 alone, Statement-1 alone is not sufficient. Check Statement-2 Alone: C > A > D, which gives no information about B and E ⇒ Statement-2 alone is not sufficient. Combine Both Statements: Combining C > A > D with A, D > {B, E, F} gives C > A > D > {B, E, F} ⇒ C is the heaviest among A, B, C, D, and E. Result: Both Statement-1 and Statement-2 are required (Note: The official UPSC answer key gives "C or D" because option (d) literally states that neither statement "alone" is sufficient, which is also true alongside (c)). Correct Answer: (c) Both Statement-1 and Statement-2 are required to answer the Question
