Civil Services Examination · Question 11
Passage—1 "In simple matters like shoe-making, we think only a specially trained person will serve our purpose, but in politics, we presume that everyone who knows how to get votes knows how to administer a State. When we are ill, we call for a trained physician, whose degree is a guarantee of specific preparation and technical competence—we do not ask for the handsomest physician, or the most eloquent one : well then, when the whole State is ill should we not look for the service and guidance of the wisest and the best?" Which one of the following statements best reflects the message of the author of the passage?
Show answer & explanationShow explanation
Answer: (C) We need to devise a method of barring incompetence from public office.
Concept: Identify the central normative message behind the author's analogy of shoe-making and medicine with politics. Analyze the Analogy: For shoe-making or treating illness, we demand technical competence rather than eloquence, yet in politics we let anyone who can get votes administer the State. Evaluate Options: Option (a) merely restates the current flawed presumption; Option (b) narrows it to formal training in administration whereas the author calls for 'the wisest and the best'; Option (c) captures the prescriptive message that incompetence should be barred from public office. Result: Option (c) best reflects the author's message. Correct Answer: (c) We need to devise a method of barring incompetence from public office.
