Civil Services Examination · Question 65
A Question is given followed by two Statements I and II. Consider the Question and the Statements. A certain amount was distributed among X, Y and Z. Question : Who received the least amount? Statement-I : X received 4/5 of what Y and Z together received. Statement-II : Y received 2/7 of what X and Z together received. Which one of the following is correct in respect of the above Question and the Statements?
Show answer & explanationShow explanation
Answer: (C) The Question can be answered by using both the Statements together, but cannot be answered using either Statement alone
Given / Concept: Let the total amount distributed be T = X + Y + Z. Check Statement-I Alone: X = (4/5)(Y + Z) ⇒ X / (X + Y + Z) = 4 / (4 + 5) = 4/9 ⇒ X = (4/9)T. Since Y + Z = (5/9)T, either Y or Z could be smaller (e.g. Y = 1/9 T, Z = 4/9 T) ⇒ Not sufficient alone. Check Statement-II Alone: Y = (2/7)(X + Z) ⇒ Y / (X + Y + Z) = 2 / (2 + 7) = 2/9 ⇒ Y = (2/9)T. Since X + Z = (7/9)T, either X or Z could be less than 2/9 T (e.g. X = 1/9 T, Z = 6/9 T) ⇒ Not sufficient alone. Combine Both Statements: Together, X = (4/9)T and Y = (2/9)T ⇒ Z = T − (4/9 + 2/9)T = (3/9)T. ⇒ Comparing 4/9 T, 2/9 T, and 3/9 T, Y received the least amount. Result: Both statements together are required to answer the question. Correct Answer: (c) The Question can be answered by using both the Statements together, but cannot be answered using either Statement alone
