UPSC PYQPrelims 2001

Civil Services Examination · Question 147

Most guitarists are bearded males. If A represents all males, B represents bearded males and C represents all male guitarists, then the correct diagram for their relation (shaded portion) is A.

Option A

B.

Option B

C.

Option C

D.

Option D
  1. A

  2. B

  3. C

  4. D

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (A) A

Explanation

Analyze Set Inclusion: We are given three sets: • A = All males • B = Bearded males • C = All male guitarists. ⇒ Because every 'bearded male' (B) is a male and every 'male guitarist' (C) is also a male, both set B and set C must be proper subsets completely enclosed inside circle A (B ⊂ A and C ⊂ A). Analyze Overlap Between B and C: ⇒ Some/most male guitarists are bearded males, while some male guitarists are not bearded, and not all bearded males are guitarists. Therefore, circles B and C intersect each other inside circle A, with the shaded intersection (B ∩ C) representing bearded male guitarists. Eliminate Options b, c & d: ⇒ In diagrams (b), (c), and (d), either circle C or circle B extends outside circle A (which would mean a 'male guitarist' or 'bearded male' is not male — a contradiction). Only Diagram (a) places both B and C entirely inside A with their overlap shaded. Result: Diagram (a) is the correct representation. Correct Answer: (a) Diagram (a)

Diagram explaining the answer