UPSC PYQPrelims 2001

Civil Services Examination · Question 149

Anand must be a vegetarian because he is a Buddhist. The argument assumes that

  1. most Buddhists are vegetarians

  2. all Buddhists are vegetarians

  3. only Buddhists are vegetarians

  4. most vegetarians are Buddhists

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (A) most Buddhists are vegetarians

Explanation

Analyze the Argument: The given argument states: • Premise: Anand is a Buddhist. • Conclusion: Therefore, Anand must be a vegetarian. Identify the Missing Link / Assumption: ⇒ The speaker infers that Anand is a vegetarian solely from the fact that he belongs to the group 'Buddhists'. Compare Options a and b: ⇒ In everyday conversational reasoning, saying 'Anand must be a vegetarian because he is a Buddhist' assumes at least that (a) most Buddhists are vegetarians (which is marked as 'Ans: a)' in the attached PDF). Note that in strict formal deductive logic, the modal word 'must' requires the universal premise (b) all Buddhists are vegetarians (which is given in standard UPSC logic keys). Following instructions, we retain the PDF key (a) and note both interpretations. Why c and d Fail: ⇒ 'Only Buddhists are vegetarians' (c) and 'most vegetarians are Buddhists' (d) reverse the direction of implication (confusing 'if Buddhist → vegetarian' with 'if vegetarian → Buddhist'). Correct Answer: (a) most Buddhists are vegetarians

Diagram explaining the answer