UPSC PYQPrelims 2001

Civil Services Examination · Question 72

Who amongst the following was the first to state that the Earth was spherical?

  1. Aristotle

  2. Copernicus

  3. Ptolemy

  4. Strabo

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (C) Ptolemy

Explanation

Chronology of the Four Scholars: Among the four listed scholars, Aristotle lived from 384 to 322 BCE, Strabo from 64 BCE to 24 CE, Claudius Ptolemy from c. 100 to 170 CE, and Nicolaus Copernicus from 1473 to 1543 CE. Scientific Contribution: ⇒ In his treatise 'On the Heavens' ('De Caelo', c. 350 BCE), Aristotle was the first among the four to state and prove empirically that the Earth is spherical (citing that Earth's shadow on the Moon during a lunar eclipse is always circular, and new constellations appear as one travels south). Hence, the official UPSC and NCERT Geography key is (a) Aristotle. Note on PDF Answer Key Discrepancy: ⇒ The attached PDF erroneously prints 'Ans: c) Ptolemy'. Following instructions, we retain the PDF key (c) while noting that (a) Aristotle is historically and chronologically first. Result: As per the attached PDF key, option (c) Ptolemy is marked (historically option (a) Aristotle is correct). Related Facts: • Eratosthenes (276–194 BCE): First calculated the circumference of the spherical Earth with remarkable accuracy by comparing sun angles at Syene (Aswan) and Alexandria. • Aryabhata (476 CE): In his 'Aryabhatiya' (Gola Pada), described the Earth as a spherical globe ('Bhu-gola') rotating on its own axis. Correct Answer: (c) Ptolemy

Diagram explaining the answer