Civil Services Examination · Question 106
P, Q, R and S are four men. P is the oldest but not the poorest. R is the richest but not the oldest. Q is older than S but not than P or R. P is richer than Q but not than S. The four men can be ordered (descending) in respect of age and richness, respectively, as
Show answer & explanationShow explanation
Answer: (B) PRQS, RSPQ
Order by Age — Descending: P is the oldest ⇒ P is 1st. Q is older than S (Q > S) but younger than both P and R (R > Q) ⇒ Age order from oldest to youngest is P > R > Q > S, i.e., PRQS. Order by Richness — Descending: R is the richest ⇒ R is 1st. P is richer than Q (P > Q) but not richer than S (S > P) ⇒ Richness order from richest to poorest is R > S > P > Q, i.e., RSPQ. Verify Extra Clues: P is not the poorest (Q is poorest ✓) and R is not the oldest (P is oldest ✓). Result: The descending orders for age and richness are PRQS, RSPQ. Shortcut: Q > S in age eliminates (d); P > Q in richness eliminates (c); R > Q in age eliminates (a) ⇒ only (b) PRQS, RSPQ remains! Correct Answer: (b) PRQS, RSPQ
