UPSC PYQPrelims 2010

Civil Services Examination · Question 106

P, Q, R and S are four men. P is the oldest but not the poorest. R is the richest but not the oldest. Q is older than S but not than P or R. P is richer than Q but not than S. The four men can be ordered (descending) in respect of age and richness, respectively, as

  1. PQRS, RPSQ

  2. PRQS, RSPQ

  3. PRQS, RSQP

  4. PRSQ, RSPQ

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (B) PRQS, RSPQ

Explanation

Order by Age — Descending: P is the oldest ⇒ P is 1st. Q is older than S (Q > S) but younger than both P and R (R > Q) ⇒ Age order from oldest to youngest is P > R > Q > S, i.e., PRQS. Order by Richness — Descending: R is the richest ⇒ R is 1st. P is richer than Q (P > Q) but not richer than S (S > P) ⇒ Richness order from richest to poorest is R > S > P > Q, i.e., RSPQ. Verify Extra Clues: P is not the poorest (Q is poorest ✓) and R is not the oldest (P is oldest ✓). Result: The descending orders for age and richness are PRQS, RSPQ. Shortcut: Q > S in age eliminates (d); P > Q in richness eliminates (c); R > Q in age eliminates (a) ⇒ only (b) PRQS, RSPQ remains! Correct Answer: (b) PRQS, RSPQ

Diagram explaining the answer