UPSC PYQPrelims 2013

Civil Services Examination · Question 75

Directions for the item: The following item describes a situation and is followed by four possible responses. Indicate the response you find most appropriate. Choose only one response for each item. The responses will be evaluated based on the level of appropriateness for the given situation. You are the head of your office. There are certain houses reserved for the allotment to the office staff and you have been given the discretion to do so. A set of rules for the allotment of the houses has been laid down by you and has been made public. Your personal secretary, who is very close to you, comes to you and pleads that as his father is seriously ill, he should be given priority in allotment of a house. The office secretariat that examined the request as per the rules turns down the request and recommends the procedure to be followed according to the rules. You do not want to annoy your personal secretary. In such circumstances, what would you do ?

  1. Call him over to your room and personally explain why the allotment cannot be done.

  2. Allot the house to him to win his loyalty.

  3. Agree with the office note to show that you are not biased and that you do not indulge in favouritism.

  4. Keep the file with you and not pass any orders.

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (A) Call him over to your room and personally explain why the allotment cannot be done.

Explanation

Concept: Balance strict adherence to publicly laid-down rules with sensitive interpersonal communication. Eliminate b & d: Option (b) violates the rules through favouritism; Option (d) is administrative indecisiveness. Compare a & c: Option (a) upholds the rules (refusing out-of-turn allotment) while personally explaining the rule constraint so the secretary is not annoyed; Option (c) also upholds the office note. Result: Option (a) is the most complete response (note: UPSC's official answer key for Series A awards full marks to both (a) and (c)). Correct Answer: (a) Call him over to your room and personally explain why the allotment cannot be done.

Diagram explaining the answer