UPSC PYQPrelims 2013

Civil Services Examination · Question 78

Directions for the item: The following item describes a situation and is followed by four possible responses. Indicate the response you find most appropriate. Choose only one response for each item. The responses will be evaluated based on the level of appropriateness for the given situation. There is a shortage of sugar in your District where you are the District Magistrate. The Government has ordered that only a maximum amount of 30 kg sugar is to be released for wedding celebrations. A son of your close friend is getting married and your friend requests you to release at least 50 kg sugar for his son's wedding. He expresses annoyance when you tell him about the Government's restrictions on this matter. He feels that since you are the District Magistrate you can release any amount. You do not want to spoil your friendship with him. In such circumstances, how would you deal with the situation ?

  1. Release the extra amount of sugar which your friend has requested for.

  2. Refuse your friend the extra amount and strictly follow the rules.

  3. Show your friend the copy of the Government instructions and then persuade him to accept the lower amount as prescribed in the rules.

  4. Advise him to directly apply to the allotting authority and inform him that you do not interfere in this matter.

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (C) Show your friend the copy of the Government instructions and then persuade him to accept the lower amount as prescribed in the rules.

Explanation

Concept: Uphold the mandatory 30 kg government ration limit while addressing the friend's misconception tactfully. Eliminate a & d: Releasing 50 kg (a) violates the government order; (d) is evasive. Compare b & c: Option (c) shows the friend the official government order (dispelling his belief that the DM can release any amount) and persuades him to accept the 30 kg limit, thereby following the rule and preserving the friendship; Option (b) also strictly follows the rules. Result: Option (c) is the best response (both (b) and (c) are credited in UPSC's official answer key). Correct Answer: (c) Show your friend the copy of the Government instructions and then persuade him to accept the lower amount as prescribed in the rules.

Diagram explaining the answer