UPSC PYQPrelims 2013

Civil Services Examination · Question 80

Directions for the item: The following item describes a situation and is followed by four possible responses. Indicate the response you find most appropriate. Choose only one response for each item. The responses will be evaluated based on the level of appropriateness for the given situation. You are a teacher in a University and are setting a question paper on a particular subject. One of your colleagues, whose son is preparing for the examination on that subject, comes to you and informs you that it is his son's last chance to pass that examination and whether you could help him by indicating what questions are going to be in the examination. In the past, your colleague had helped you in another matter. Your colleague informs you that his son will suffer from depression if he fails in this examination. In such circumstances, what would you do ?

  1. In view of the help he had given you, extend your help to him.

  2. Regret that you cannot be of any help to him.

  3. Explain to your colleague that this would be violating the trust of the University authorities and you are not in a position to help him.

  4. Report the conduct of your colleague to the higher authorities.

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (C) Explain to your colleague that this would be violating the trust of the University authorities and you are not in a position to help him.

Explanation

Concept: Uphold absolute academic integrity and confidentiality when setting a university examination paper, regardless of personal obligations. Eliminate a: Leaking examination questions (a) is a severe breach of ethics and institutional trust. Compare b & c: Option (c) firmly declines the request while clearly explaining to the colleague that leaking questions would violate the trust of the University authorities; Option (b) also politely refuses any help. Result: Option (c) is the most appropriate response (both (b) and (c) are credited in UPSC's official answer key). Correct Answer: (c) Explain to your colleague that this would be violating the trust of the University authorities and you are not in a position to help him.

Diagram explaining the answer