UPSC PYQPrelims 2015

Civil Services Examination · Question 51

The number of persons who read magazine X only is thrice the number of persons who read magazine Y. The number of persons who read magazine Y only is thrice the number of persons who read magazine X. Then, which of the following conclusions can be drawn? 1. The number of persons who read both the magazines is twice the number of persons who read only magazine X. 2. The total number of persons who read either one magazine or both the magazines is twice the number of persons who read both the magazines. Select the correct answer using the code given below:

  1. 1 only

  2. 2 only

  3. Both 1 and 2

  4. Neither 1 nor 2

Show answer & explanationShow explanation

Answer: (C) Both 1 and 2

Explanation

Given / Concept: Let x = persons reading X only, y = persons reading Y only, and b = persons reading both magazines. Note on Official UPSC Key: Literally, x = 3(y + b) and y = 3(x + b) ⇒ x + y = 3(x + y) + 6b ⇒ 2(x + y) + 6b = 0, which is impossible for positive counts. Due to this phrasing flaw, UPSC officially dropped this question ('X' in the official key). Intended Equations: The intended condition is that readers of magazine X are thrice "Y only" and readers of magazine Y are thrice "X only" ⇒ x + b = 3y and y + b = 3x. Check Statements 1 and 2: Subtracting gives x − y = 3(y − x) ⇒ x = y, and x + b = 3x ⇒ b = 2x (Statement 1 is true). Total readers = x + y + b = 4x = 2b (Statement 2 is true). Result: Both statements 1 and 2 follow under the intended mathematical formulation. Correct Answer: (c) Both 1 and 2

Diagram explaining the answer