Civil Services Examination · Question 72
Lakshmi, her brother, her daughter and her son are badminton players. A game of doubles is about to begin : (i) Lakshmi's brother is directly across the net from her daughter. (ii) Her son is diagonally across the net from the worst player's sibling. (iii) The best player and the worst player are on the same side of the net. Who is the best player?
Show answer & explanationShow explanation
Answer: (A) Her brother
Given: Four players in a doubles court: Lakshmi (L), Brother (B), Daughter (D), and Son (S). Determine teams/sides: By (i), B is directly across the net from D. In doubles, if B and S were on the same side, then L would be on D's side and diagonally opposite B, meaning S would be diagonally opposite L (who is B's sibling), which would make B the worst player and S the best player—contradicting (iii) that Best and Worst are on the same side! Therefore, (B and L) are on Side 1, and (D and S) are on Side 2. Apply Clue ii: Since B is directly across from D, S (next to D on Side 2) is diagonally across from B (on Side 1). By (ii), the person diagonally across from S is 'the worst player's sibling' ⇒ B is the worst player's sibling ⇒ Lakshmi (L) is the worst player. Apply Clue iii: The best player and the worst player (Lakshmi) are on the same side of the net (Side 1). Since Side 1 consists of Lakshmi and her brother, her brother is the best player. Correct Answer: (a) Her brother
